San Juan - San Juan

After takeoff from runway 09, a climbing left turn was made. At about 1,000 feet, the #2 (right) engine backfired, emitted flames, and lost power. The captain instructed the copilot to feather the #2 propeller, which the copilot initiated with the feathering button. When the captain requested gear and flap extension, the copilot released the feathering button which did not remain engaged, contrary to system design. The airplane had arrived on a left downwind abeam the landing area at 500 feet and 95 to 100 knots. The captain turned toward the runway, then he ordered the gear and flaps to be retracted and initiated a go-around by increasing the left throttle without increasing propeller speed. A right turn was then made, and the airplane eventually crashed about 3 miles from the runway. During a postaccident examination, the propellers were found unfeathered, and the right engine fuel selector was in the main tank position. The emergency procedure listed the best single engine speed as 85 knots. The procedure for engine fire/failure was to feather the propeller and to move the respective fuel selector to 'OFF.' Examination revealed the number 11 cylinder on the right engine was cracked. There was evidence of fire, adjacent to the cylinder on the cowling, which consisted of scorching, sooting, and a burned through area of the underside of the right engine cowling. The copilot indicated a previous problem with the feathering system, but maintenance records did not contain any previous discrepancies regarding this anomaly.

Flight / Schedule

San Juan - San Juan

Aircraft

Douglas DC-3

Registration

N37AP

MSN

4430

Year of Manufacture

1942

Date

October 31, 1996 at 03:30 AM

Type

CRASH

Flight Type

Positioning

Flight Phase

Takeoff (climb)

Crash Site

Airport (less than 10 km from airport)

Crash Location

San Juan-Isla Grande (Fernando Luis Ribas Dominicci) All Puerto Rico

Region

Central America • Puerto Rico

Crash Cause

Technical failure

Narrative Report

On October 31, 1996 at 03:30 AM, San Juan - San Juan experienced a crash involving Douglas DC-3, operated by Flamenco Airways, with the event recorded near San Juan-Isla Grande (Fernando Luis Ribas Dominicci) All Puerto Rico.

The flight was categorized as positioning and the reported phase was takeoff (climb) at a airport (less than 10 km from airport) crash site.

3 people were known to be on board, 0 fatalities were recorded, 3 survivors were identified or estimated. This corresponds to an estimated fatality rate of 0.0%.

Crew on board: 3, crew fatalities: 0, passengers on board: 0, passenger fatalities: 0, other fatalities: 0.

The listed crash cause is technical failure. After takeoff from runway 09, a climbing left turn was made. At about 1,000 feet, the #2 (right) engine backfired, emitted flames, and lost power. The captain instructed the copilot to feather the #2 propeller, which the copilot initiated with the feathering button. When the captain requested gear and flap extension, the copilot released the feathering button which did not remain engaged, contrary to system design. The airplane had arrived on a left downwind abeam the landing area at 500 feet and 95 to 100 knots. The captain turned toward the runway, then he ordered the gear and flaps to be retracted and initiated a go-around by increasing the left throttle without increasing propeller speed. A right turn was then made, and the airplane eventually crashed about 3 miles from the runway. During a postaccident examination, the propellers were found unfeathered, and the right engine fuel selector was in the main tank position. The emergency procedure listed the best single engine speed as 85 knots. The procedure for engine fire/failure was to feather the propeller and to move the respective fuel selector to 'OFF.' Examination revealed the number 11 cylinder on the right engine was cracked. There was evidence of fire, adjacent to the cylinder on the cowling, which consisted of scorching, sooting, and a burned through area of the underside of the right engine cowling. The copilot indicated a previous problem with the feathering system, but maintenance records did not contain any previous discrepancies regarding this anomaly.

Aircraft reference details include registration N37AP, MSN 4430, year of manufacture 1942.

Fatalities

Total

0

Crew

0

Passengers

0

Other

0

Crash Summary

After takeoff from runway 09, a climbing left turn was made. At about 1,000 feet, the #2 (right) engine backfired, emitted flames, and lost power. The captain instructed the copilot to feather the #2 propeller, which the copilot initiated with the feathering button. When the captain requested gear and flap extension, the copilot released the feathering button which did not remain engaged, contrary to system design. The airplane had arrived on a left downwind abeam the landing area at 500 feet and 95 to 100 knots. The captain turned toward the runway, then he ordered the gear and flaps to be retracted and initiated a go-around by increasing the left throttle without increasing propeller speed. A right turn was then made, and the airplane eventually crashed about 3 miles from the runway. During a postaccident examination, the propellers were found unfeathered, and the right engine fuel selector was in the main tank position. The emergency procedure listed the best single engine speed as 85 knots. The procedure for engine fire/failure was to feather the propeller and to move the respective fuel selector to 'OFF.' Examination revealed the number 11 cylinder on the right engine was cracked. There was evidence of fire, adjacent to the cylinder on the cowling, which consisted of scorching, sooting, and a burned through area of the underside of the right engine cowling. The copilot indicated a previous problem with the feathering system, but maintenance records did not contain any previous discrepancies regarding this anomaly.

Cause: Technical failure

Occupants & Outcome

Crew On Board

3

Passengers On Board

0

Estimated Survivors

3

Fatality Rate

0.0%

Known people on board: 3

Operational Details

Schedule / Flight

San Juan - San Juan

Flight Type

Positioning

Flight Phase

Takeoff (climb)

Crash Site

Airport (less than 10 km from airport)

Region / Country

Central America • Puerto Rico

Aircraft Details

Aircraft

Douglas DC-3

Registration

N37AP

MSN

4430

Year of Manufacture

1942

Similar Plane Crashes

October 29, 1928 at 12:00 AM

Pan American World Airways - PAA

Loening C-W Air Yacht

While taking off from the bay in Puerto Rico, the seaplane hit an embankment and came to rest. Both crew members were rescued and the aircraft sank.

August 12, 1931 at 12:00 AM

Pan American World Airways - PAA

Sikorsky S-38

Upon landing off San Juan, the floatplane collided with an undetermined floating object and was damaged beyond repair. All nine occupants were rescued.

February 9, 1937 at 08:50 PM11 Fatalities

United Airlines

Douglas DC-3

On final approach, the aircraft lost 400 feet in few seconds and eventually crashed into the bay of San Francisco, some two miles off the airport. All eleven occupants were killed. Crew: A. R. Thompson, pilot, Joe Decesaro, copilot, Ruth Kimmel, stewardess.

April 3, 1937 at 03:30 PM8 Fatalities

KLM Royal Dutch Airlines - Koninklijke Luchtvaart Maatschappij

Douglas DC-3

The aircraft was on a delivery flight to the Dutch National Company based in Amsterdam and should be flown from Long Beach to New York with intermediate stops in Phoenix and Kansas City. While proceeding in poor weather conditions, aircraft hit Baldy Peak located some 250 km northeast of Phoenix. All eight occupants were killed.

October 6, 1937 at 12:25 PM4 Fatalities

KLM Royal Dutch Airlines - Koninklijke Luchtvaart Maatschappij

Douglas DC-3

Shortly after takeoff from Palembang-Talang Airport, while in initial climb, the left engine failed. Crew decided to return for a safe landing but the aircraft hit tree tops, stalled and crashed near the airport. The cockpit was destroyed and separated from the rest of the aircraft, killing three crew. A passenger was killed as well. The aircraft was christened 'Specht'. Crew: F.M. Stork, pilot, † H.J. Groeneveld, copilot, J. J. Ruben, engineer, † J. J. Stodieck, radio. †

October 17, 1937 at 09:00 PM19 Fatalities

United Airlines

Douglas DC-3

While cruising at 10,000 feet at night and in bad weather conditions, pilot tried to contact ATC without any success. He could not receive any signal from the regional beacon and decided to continue ahead to Salt Lake City Airport. Few minutes later, in low visibility, the aircraft hit the Haydens Peak at a height of 10,000 feet and located 81 km east from Salt Lake City and 32 km southwest from Knight. All 19 occupants were killed. Up to date, worst plane crash in the US. Crew: Earl D. Woodgerd, pilot, John B. Adams, copilot, Leah Derr, stewardess.